All CATEGORIES
☰ Menu
The HeldenFiles Online

Does "Idol" Have To Be This Bad This Early?

By admin Published: February 26, 2010

The show has made a fair number of on-air apologies for contestant nervousness in the early going, and the group of performers does seem raw. But I went back to look at my notes on the Top 36 from a year ago, and saw that not everyone sucked, and there was a lot more positive to talk about than there has been with this year's Top 24.

Early on, some performers were making a mark, even if some of that mark was made by the comedy stylings of Nick Mitchell/Norman Gentle. (On the other hand, Kris Allen was really uninteresting at this point.)

Allison Iraheta performed "Alone" that first go-round, the judges were euphoric, and I said: "Major goosebumps. A little screechy near the end, but she's a major singer." Adam Lambert, with "Satisfaction," had 3/4 of the judges ecstatic and Simon pegging it as a "love it or hate it" performance. Danny Gokey's "Hero" was strong in comparison to 11 weak performances, but it still stood out more than a lot of what we are hearing right now. Same thing with Lil Rounds, good on a not-great night then, and better than what we currently have.

So there was plenty to discuss then compared to now.

Print
Add This
The HeldenFiles Online Archives

SUBSCRIBE VIA RSS

OHIO.COM VIDEOS

Blogs:

Heldenfels' mailbag

Prev Next

INFORMATIONAL PAGES