Events Calendar
In This Section
Most Read Stories
Police accuse bank robbery suspect of gobbling up note (with dashcam video)
Man found dead in North Akron home is identified
Dad accused of forcing son into field, killing him
NFL star Chris Spielman's wife loses cancer battle
Coventry man killed in crash at I-77 ramp
College student mistaken for deer, shot to death
Man allegedly paid teens to spit in his face
Retired firefighter who broke color barrier among those being honored
Indians add 7 players to 40-man roster
Blogs:
Pets:
Cat-loving chihuahua suckles seven abandoned kittens
The Heldenfiles:
Friday Night Notebook
Patrick McManamon:
For your Saturday entertainment …
Akron Zips:
Two blowouts, one night
Tribe Matters:
Seven players added to Tribe’s 40-man roster
Cleveland Browns:
Holmgren expresses interest in Browns position
Kent State Sports:
Singletary update
Cleveland Cavaliers:
Gameblog: Cavs at Indiana Pacers – Here’s to LBJ and Free Throws
Buckeye Blogging:
OSU – Michigan college football rivals meet in Baghdad
Varsity Letters:
Bowling season starts today
All Da King's Men:
Headed For Disaster
Blog of Mass Destruction:
Will Health Care Reform Pass?
Akron Law Café:
Federal Judge Declares DOMA Unconstitutional
See Jane Style:
Vintage Chic
Car Chase:
TIME TO GET YOUR COLLECTOR CARS WINTERIZED
Let's Talk Real Estate:
Silverdome Potentially SOLD!
Ohio Travels with Betty:
George is looking for a Thanksgiving buffet in Akron.
Sound Check:
Steely Dan Plays "The Royal Scam" at E.J. Thomas Hall
HRLite House:
Colloquium at University of Akron
Akron Gamer:
Nintendo's Mario endures even as games come and go
Outcry over proposal pits some dairy farmers, consumers against state
By Dennis J. Willard
Beacon Journal Columbus Bureau
Published on Thursday, Mar 13, 2008
COLUMBUS: Got milk controversy.
Whenever farmers or milk producers state their cartons are ''rbST-free,'' an acronym for Monsanto's artificial growth hormone recombinant bovine somatotropin, the ag-tech giant wants equal time on the label.
Monsanto and the Ohio Farm Bureau have lobbied in Ohio to ensure ''rbST-free'' milk labels also contain a disclaimer in the same size and color typeface stating the U.S. Food and Drug Administration has found no significant difference between milk from cows injected or not injected with the artificial hormone.
Gov. Ted Strickland agreed, issuing an emergency rule on Feb. 7 through the Ohio Department of Agriculture granting Monsanto's and the farm bureau's wish.
Critics, including the International Dairy Foods Association, the Ohio Farmers Union, organic milk producers and environmental groups, maintain the equal-time label is burdensome and effectively kills any effort to market milk as rbST-free.
Some farmers in Ohio have felt pressured by the Kroger Co. and other large distributors to stop injecting their cows with artificial hormones or risk being left off of grocery chain shelves.
The department has until 5 p.m. today to decide whether to move ahead with plans to make the emergency rule permanent through approval from the Joint Committee on Agency Rule Review (JCARR).
On Wednesday, Lewis R. Jones, the department's dairy division chief, and legal counsel David Gorman listened to 27 witnesses testify for more than four hours. The majority opposed Strickland's disclaimer rule.
The hearing would have been longer, but Jones and Gorman asked no questions and those who wanted to add more to their testimony had until the end of the day to put their rebuttals in writing.
Afterward, Jones said leaders in the department, including the director, Robert Boggs, would meet, review the testimony and decide whether to rescind the order, recommend changes or submit the rule to JCARR as originally written.
For more than 14 years, since the FDA approved the use of rbST, more and more farmers and milk producers have labeled their product as hormone free, especially in recent years, as organic goods have become more popular and profitable.
Lawyers and scientists lined up Wednesday, arguing over whether Monsanto's hormone has been banned in Canada and a large part of the European Union, if Strickland's rule violates Interstate Commerce rights, the FDA's credibility and the warnings on rbST's packaging.
They also debated the definition of free speech, with each side having a different take on what is needed to fully inform the public.
Critics of the rule argue what is known as ''absence labeling'' has worked well for more than a decade. When producers state something is rbST-free, they are absence labeling.
Monsanto believes absence labeling sends a message that the hormone is inherently bad, and points out that the FDA approved rbST.
Stacey Slater, Monsanto's assistant general counsel, told Lewis and Gorman that the governor's rule ensures the FDA's findings are fully disclosed.
She said producers do not have to label their milk, but if they insist they are hormone free then they must explain the ''whole truth'' to consumers.
Jerry Slominski, senior vice-president for the dairy foods association, said the rule should be rescinded because consumers want more choices in the dairy case, not fewer.
Slominski said the administration was engaging in a debate that will ultimately lead to a loss of consumer confidence and trust in dairy products.
Brendon Cull, representing Kroger, said his company pays a premium for milk that is rbST-free because it became clear from feedback that customers are demanding it.
''We believe strongly that our milk, which is no longer from cows treated with rbST, should be labeled as such,'' Cull said.
Rob Bouick, an Ohio dairy farmer, applauded Strickland and the department for having the courage to stand up to Kroger, the dairy foods association and other ''anti-technology activists'' that he said were using demagoguery to exploit the labeling issue.
Bouick said the milk marketers forced him to stop using rbST or face not having his milk on grocery shelves, and his production fell 20 percent.
''IDFA claims they speak for farmers. They don't speak for me,'' Bouick said.
James Armstrong, a consumer from Columbus, said he grew up on a family farm in Nebraska and is careful to read labels to avoid artificial ingredients.
''I just want the plain simple truth,'' Armstrong said.
Dennis J. Willard can be reached at 614-224-1613 or dwillard@thebeaconjournal.com.
COLUMBUS: Got milk controversy.
Get the full article here.
Comments
Click here to post your comments
