The fictional writer A.N. Dyer — Andrew to his family — is dying as David Gilbert’s & Sons opens. Dyer is in the mold of J.D. Salinger: When he was in his 20s, he wrote a book about his New England prep school whose portrait of teenage angst and white privilege rivaled The Catcher in the Rye.
Dyer is “the quintessential New York writer.” And his gloomy presence is at the heart of & Sons, whose most notable achievement is its portrait of that most respected and mysterious of artistic types: the great novelist. Dyer’s success and the way he achieved it — by isolating himself from his family and mining their lives — has shaped the fate of anyone who’s ever loved him, including his sons, Andy, Jaime and Richard.
“You know how many copies Ampersand has sold since its publication?” a Hollywood producer asks Richard, a former addict and aspiring screenwriter who’s the oldest of the Dyer progeny. “Over forty-five million. … And every year it sells about a hundred thousand more.”
The producer wants to buy a screenplay Richard has written, but only if Richard can get his famously reclusive father to give him an option to bring Ampersand to film. This is one of many deliciously complicated and cringe-worthy moments in & Sons, and it comes with an additional twist — because as Richard travels to New York with his family to make this request, his teenage son is rereading grandfather Dyer’s famous novel, and absolutely loving it.
“What’s that line from Ampersand, Dad?” the son asks. “ ‘Give it time and shame eventually clambers back as pride.’ ”
In & Sons, all the pride of Dyer’s literary career has clambered back as personal shame. He’s a wreck. Once a writer with an undeniable gift of language and observation, Dyer is now a septuagenarian ensconced in his apartment overlooking Central Park that is the legacy of his well-heeled parents. American readers have been fed a steady diet of art about these kinds of Manhattanites over the past century. And Gilbert, the author of the novel The Normals, is at his best and is most intriguing when he dives into the myth of the specialness of Gotham and dissects it.
“I slipped further into A.N. Dyer’s world,” says the narrator of & Sons, Philip Topping, son of the late Charles Topping, Dyer’s lifelong friend. When Dyer agrees to read the eulogy at the elder Topping’s funeral, Philip gets sucked back into the family drama.
Richard’s wife and children have never met his famous father, and when he brings them to New York from Los Angeles, they are “tourists,” and “for that reason their faces lacked a certain patina, of the city in their blood, I suppose, which made them seem shiny, untainted by the everyday corrosions of ambition,” Gilbert writes.
Andrew Dyer is a confounding, largely unsympathetic character who encapsulates all the contradictions of New York intellectual society. His humanity and hopefulness give his books a huge following (Gilbert has great fun giving us excerpts of Dyer’s many opuses), but he’ll do just about anything to achieve his literary ends (including violating confidences shared by his children). And when he achieves great success, even that leaves him embittered.
But & Sons has bigger ambitions than being a mere character study. Gilbert is trying to write a sweeping novel about a family and the times it lives in — and a work that says something about filial love and the creative process. Unfortunately, when the legendary author steps off stage, the rest of the Dyers aren’t quite as compelling.
Gilbert’s long descriptions of the contents of one son’s closets, for example, and the details of book parties would be a lot more interesting if they weren’t so familiar. Hollywood has its usual cliched cameo. And when we’re in Manhattan, & Sons often treats the city with too much nostalgia and reverence. Nor is Gilbert nearly as ruthless with his secondary characters as the fictional Dyer (or Salinger) might have been. As a result, they often lack an edge to match the gravity of the themes he’s taken up.
None of this should detract too much from the larger achievement. Gilbert has great narrative gifts and a wonderful eye for the madness of families and the madness of writers. & Sons creates an author who is so real and flawed that the reader feels he understands American literature itself a little better after reading his story.