COLUMBUS: The Libertarian Party of Ohio immediately appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday after a lower court denied its attempt to get a gubernatorial candidate on Tuesday’s primary ballot.
Their candidate, Charlie Earl, was disqualified by Secretary of State Jon Husted after his nominating petitions were challenged. Husted agreed with a hearing officer who found two Earl petitioners failed to properly disclose their employers.
Libertarians sought to reinstate Earl’s ballot status, arguing that Husted’s ruling violated petition circulators’ First Amendment rights and conflicted with previous state rulings allowing them to submit signatures without declaring an employer.
With five days until the election, the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati said Thursday the party was too unlikely to succeed in a First Amendment challenge to Husted’s ruling to proceed.
The three-judge panel acknowledged the decision could present “severe and irreparable harm” on the party and likely undermine its status as a ballot-qualified party in the state.
“We note that the LPO has struggled to become and remain a ballot-qualified party in Ohio, and we acknowledge that this decision entails that their efforts must continue still,” the opinion said. “But we also note that we decide one case at a time, on the record before us. In so doing, we preserve the First Amendment’s primary place in our democracy over the long run.”
Earl’s candidacy has the potential to draw votes from Republican Gov. John Kasich. The incumbent faces likely Democratic challenger Ed FitzGerald, the Cuyahoga County executive in November.